Beyond "Nice": How Emerging Leaders Master Authentic Assertiveness
In my executive coaching practice, one topic surfaces repeatedly with up-and-coming leaders: assertiveness.
This is particularly common among high-potential professionals and first-generation immigrants raised in cultures where empathy, humility, and deference to authority are deeply ingrained. While these traits are extraordinary strengths for building relationships and leading with compassion, they can inadvertently create friction when a leader needs to take a firm stand.
Navigating the shift from automatic deference to authentic assertiveness isn't about changing who you are—it’s about redefining what assertiveness actually means. Here is a look inside the coaching journey that helps leaders move from hesitation to empowered, value-aligned action.
1. Unpacking the Definition
When a client shares that they want to be more assertive, we always start with a foundational question: “What does assertiveness mean to you?”
The answers vary dramatically:
“Being firm or strict.”
“Claiming my rights.”
“Frankly expressing how I feel.”
“Demanding fairness.”
By expanding the conversation beyond the office to include home life and community, clients begin to see new perspectives. A richer definition emerges along the lines of assertiveness is sharing what you think and feel, in an agreeable and respectful manner—without hesitation, shyness, or aggression.
2. Uncovering the Root Blockers
Once we establish what assertiveness looks like, we explore: “What comes in the way of you being assertive?”
This is where individual challenges surface. Emerging Leaders with high levels of empathy often worry about:
A fear of being perceived as too harsh or aggressive.
The anxiety of evoking a negative reaction from the other party.
A deep discomfort with potential confrontation.
We also explore past moments where clients felt an internal pull to speak up but stayed silent instead. Clients confess that walking out of a meeting having agreed to an outcome that feels wrong leaves them emotionally drained and they end up carrying a heavy burden of guilt. Allowing space to process these emotions is critical—it helps my clients realize the real cost of silence and clarifies who they want to become.
3. The "Aha!" Moment: Shifting from Statements to Inquiry
The breakthrough often happens when we explore how to break the cycle of fear and hesitation.
When faced with a tough conversation, many assume being assertive means delivering a perfect, hard-hitting response. But assertiveness doesn't require having all the answers or making immediate demands. Assertiveness can be activated through powerful, open questions.
Instead of reacting defensively or shutting down, leaders learn to ask exploratory questions to understand the other party's underlying interests, while expressing their interests as well. This shifts the dynamic from a confrontation into a collaborative effort to co-create win-win solutions.
4. Grounding Assertiveness in Core Values
The second key breakthrough occurs when I ask questions on what my clients' values are and what alignment they see - if any - between their assertiveness posture and their values. This is when clients gain insights that they would like to align their communication with their core values, such as fairness, transparency, and care for others.
Clients begin to view assertiveness not as a self-serving behavior, but as a way to uphold transparency and mutual respect. When I follow-up with the question what benefits do you then see on this alignment, they mention that the guilt vanishes and I can see a shift in their energy; they seem to have gained a new insight and solution to their issue. What I often hear is along the lines of "I am not attacking the other person; I am honouring my values. Grounding my actions in my core values provide me the courage to speak up authentically, replacing shyness with quiet confidence".
5. Moving Off Auto-Pilot
The final step is translating insight into daily practice. Clients redefine what assertiveness means for their personal leadership style and commit to a critical habit change: stopping the auto-pilot response.
Instead of defaulting to immediate agreement out of habit:
Pause in the moment an opportunity to be assertive arises.
Ask exploratory questions to understand interests and options.
Respond in alignment with your values to build a collaborative outcome.
The Transformation
Watching a leader move through this process—from feeling stuck and conflicted to leaving a session energized, relieved, and smiling—is one of the most rewarding parts of executive coaching.
Assertiveness isn't about loud dominance. It is the quiet power of knowing your values, respecting others, and courageously co-creating win-win outcomes for everyone involved.
Would you like to become more assertive? Feel free to book a free discovery call from my website at www.SuccessSupport.ca
Back to LinkedIn
Comments