Influence Without Authority: Coaching Insights for Executives

Influence is about bringing others along on a journey they want to be part of

One of the most frequent and pressing challenges my executive coaching clients bring to our sessions is this: "How do I influence stakeholders I have no authority over?" Whether they are navigating internal matrixed environments, persuading external investors, or building bridges across ecosystems, the ability to influence without formal power is a key success factor in leadership today.

The Influence Dilemma

Influence in modern organizations often doesn’t come from a title or direct reporting line. In fact, the higher one rises in leadership, the more success depends on persuasion, collaboration, and strategic alignment across diverse stakeholders—many of whom may have competing priorities, limited time, or their own power bases.

Yet, I’ve observed a recurring theme in my coaching sessions: executives frequently lack clarity on what they’re actually trying to influence.

Clarity Before Strategy

Before we can talk tactics—elevator pitches, stakeholder maps, or negotiation frameworks—we first explore intent. What decision or behavior change are you trying to drive? What impact are you hoping for? Too often, this foundational clarity is missing, which undermines any attempts at persuasion.

Clarity of purpose allows us to align our ask with the stakeholder's reality.

Understanding Stakeholder Needs

Once clarity is established, the next coaching focus is empathy and understanding. Have you deeply explored what matters to the stakeholder? What’s keeping them up at night? What do they stand to gain—or lose—from saying “yes” to your proposal?

Successful influencers listen more than they speak. I often challenge clients to step into their stakeholders’ shoes and map out interests, priorities, and constraints before crafting their approach.

Focused Asks: Less is More

Another trap I see is the scattergun approach—presenting stakeholders with a laundry list of requests. This not only overwhelms but risks disengagement. Influence is more effective when your ask is targeted, prioritized, and framed around what matters most to the other party.

Helping clients laser-focus on one or two high-impact asks increases clarity, creates momentum, and builds credibility over time.

Designing Win-Win Scenarios

Influence isn’t about pushing an agenda—it’s about creating alignment. In my coaching conversations, my clients unlock ways to create win-win outcomes. What would make your stakeholder feel successful? How can your goal also support theirs?

Often, the breakthrough comes when clients shift from “How do I get them to say yes to me?” to “How do I help them win by saying yes?”

The Relationship Factor

A final—and often underleveraged—element of influence is informal relationship-building. Influence is far easier when there is trust and familiarity outside the boardroom. Yet many clients struggle with finding authentic ways to build rapport, especially across lines of gender, culture, or hierarchy.

Coaching often opens space to navigate these dynamics—how to build connection while being mindful of inclusion, how to network without discomfort, and how to bring one’s full, authentic self into influence conversations.

Final Thoughts

Influencing without authority is not a single skill—it is a composite of clarity, empathy, focus, creativity, and relationship-building. As an executive coach, my role is to help clients uncover these capacities within themselves, adapt them to their context, and lead with purpose and presence.

Influence, after all, is not just about getting your way—it’s about bringing others along on a journey they want to be part of.

Call to Action: Is developing your ability to influence critical for your leadership success? Feel free to book a complimentary Discovery call, using that option from my website: www.SuccessSupport.ca

Back to my LinkedIn post